Quantity, Calculations, Totals & an extra $40,000.000

I am attempting to build a form that will present a product that has 2 different prices based on quantity ordered. If a user enter less than 36 in the Quantity Field, then the price is $69.95 per. If the user enters more than 35 in the Quantity Field, then the price is $34.95 per.
Here is my current setup:

• Quantity Field ( Labelled "4th Quarter")
  No special properties
• Product Field (Labelled "Special Pricing")
  Properties: Calculation and Merger Tag of {4th Quarter:15} * 34.95
  Conditional Logic (All): Show if 4th Quarter is greater than 35
• Product Field (Labelled "Regular Pricing")
  Properties: Calculation and Merger Tag of {4th Quarter:15} * 69.95
  Conditional Logic (All): Show if 4th Quarter is greater than 0
  Show if 4th Quarter is less than 36
• Total Field

If 35 or less is entered into the Quantity Field, all is well and the Total Field displays the correct amount. However, if 36 (or more) is entered into the Quantity Field, the form calculates it, puts the total in the Price, but then multiplies the Price by 34.95 to get a Total. In other words:

35 quantity X 69.95 = Price and Total displaying $2,448.25 (CORRECT)
36 quantity X 34.95 = Price of $1,258.20 and a Total of $45,295.20 (INCORRECT)

Soooooo...what am I doing wrong

TIA
Rat

Sure thing, David. The logic to both is set to ALL ( I did a poor job of notating that above.) Screenies are here --> https://www.dropbox.com/sh/eo11rfyn6hrl9dn/dzm5amLlG_

And yes, same error with anything 36+.

CODE --> http://pastie.org/5450022
URL: http://4dsupplements.com/coaches-special-pricing/
TEMP PW: Ju5t4Ud3v5!

Any updates on this?