OK, so I've spent about two hours researching this:
I've read pretty much every support thread I can find, including this...
...and even this...
...I've tried everything suggested in these threads (and then some) and I'm still stuck.
Here's what I do know:
I'm using the latest version of GravityForms (just purchased this past weekend).
Hosting WordPress through GoDaddy (I know, I know).
BUT... have been using GoDaddy email services for years with no issue.
Cannot get GravityForms to fire off mails from forms at http://www.wallysclub.com/wordpress
Two forms : one under Contact Us, and the other connected to the top post on the main page.
Was able to get notifications to fire off natively in WordPress through GoDaddy using
other (free) form tools like Grunion. I'd rather use Gravity for the functionality and ease of use though.
Have tried all manner of email combinations to see if the email will send, including using my gmail accounts as test mails and changing the default admin mail to my gmail account.
Using the ConfigureSMTP plug-in, I'm able to set any sort of configuration I please, and get a test email to fire off no problem -- including defaulting to Gmail-mode, and using smtpout.secureserver.net:80 and relay-hosting.secureserver.net:25. SMTPAuth on or off, account info provided or not, doesn't matter. Test emails fire off reliably regardless of what email account combinations I use -- godaddy to gmail, gmail to godaddy, godaddy to godaddy.
And after all this, I still cannot get GravityForms to fire off a notification mail. Not a single mail, or a routed conditional mail. Not to/through Gmail, not to/through any of the dozen GoDaddy accounts I have.
There has to be something I'm missing...
Carl, I'm happy to provide you with wp-admin access to help troubleshoot. Just let me know how to provide that to you securely.
Thanks much (in advance).